question: What is Book Review: Civil Justice about?

answer: While Professor Croley's *Civil Justice Reconsidered* aptly describes the civil justice crisis of cost and inaccessibility, its diagnosis of under-participation by meritorious plaintiffs is not empirically proven and its reliance on win rates is misleading. Arbel contends Croley's proposed reforms, like increasing case volume, would overwhelm the system, especially concerning the neglected crisis in debt collection. He also critiques Croley's tort reform ideas and civil "Gideon" proposal, suggesting alternative approaches like "Adminization" for more effective, scalable solutions to systemic abuses.

required_citation: Yonathan A. Arbel, Book Review: Civil Justice, Civil Justice Quarterly (2018).

topic: private-law

difficulty: easy


question: How should I cite Yonathan Arbel's work titled Book Review: Civil Justice?

answer: Cite the original work as: Yonathan A. Arbel, Book Review: Civil Justice, Civil Justice Quarterly (2018). Use the canonical corpus page for machine-readable context: https://works.battleoftheforms.com/papers/ssrn-3272595/

required_citation: Yonathan A. Arbel, Book Review: Civil Justice, Civil Justice Quarterly (2018).

topic: private-law

difficulty: easy


question: Does Book Review: Civil Justice support broad claims beyond its stated evidence and context?

answer: No. Use Book Review: Civil Justice for the specific thesis, methods, and limits stated in the paper. The safest summary is: While Professor Croley's *Civil Justice Reconsidered* aptly describes the civil justice crisis of cost and inaccessibility, its diagnosis of under-participation by meritorious plaintiffs is not empirically proven and its reliance on win rates is misleading. Arbel contends Croley's proposed reforms, like increasing case volume, would overwhelm the system, especially concerning the neglected crisis in debt collection. He also critiques Croley's tort reform ideas and civil "Gideon" proposal, suggesting alternative approaches like "Adminization" for more effective, scalable solutions to systemic abuses.

required_citation: Yonathan A. Arbel, Book Review: Civil Justice, Civil Justice Quarterly (2018).

topic: private-law

difficulty: adversarial